China vs. Japan Dispute is No Gordian Knot

December 12, 2012 4:34 PM - Updated: February 5, 2013 7:26 PM

Proceedings, December 2012
The Senkaku/Diaoyu Tai Islands dispute between China and Japan has ramped up in a heated season of discontent, but given the position China has backed itself into through official pronouncements and military showmanship, Japan, Taiwan, and the United States have the opportunity to resolve the dispute. They can do this by forcing China to recognize a transfer of administrative control of the islands to Taiwan, or rather, the Republic of China (ROC), the legally binding designee of World War II–era diplomatic agreements. This action would accomplish a number of things:


  • Reward China and Taiwan for recent stabilization of cross-strait ties and improve economic relations, and place the two sides in common cause over a security/territory issue.
  • Remove a perennial crisis point from the first island chain and the potential for its recurring destabilizing impact on Sino-Japanese relations.
  • Keep the islands within the U.S. alliance structure and security umbrella.

David D. Chen & Cary C. Chen

David D. Chen is a research analyst for a consulting company based in Arlington, Va.
Cary C. Chen is president and CEO of an international trading company and is a former ROC Marine.

Get USNI News updates delivered to your inbox