Home » Foreign Forces » U.S. 7th Fleet CO: Japanese Patrols of South China Sea ‘Makes Sense’


U.S. 7th Fleet CO: Japanese Patrols of South China Sea ‘Makes Sense’

USS Pinckney (DDG-91) and the Japan Maritime Self-Defense Force (JMSDF) ships near Guam on July 8, 2014. US Navy Photo

USS Pinckney (DDG-91) and the Japan Maritime Self-Defense Force (JMSDF) ships near Guam on July 8, 2014. US Navy Photo

This post has been updated to include a quote from the Singapore’s minister for foreign affairs and law, K. Shanmugam.

The commander of U.S. 7th Fleet said Japan should start patrolling the South China Sea and said China’s claims in the region are resulting in, “unnecessary friction” with neighbors.

In a Thursday interview with news service Reuters, Vice Adm. Robert Thomas said Japan could provide a, “stabilizing function” as tensions resulting from overlapping regional claims rise and China’s fishing and naval fleets continue to grow.

“I think that [Japan Maritime Self Defense Forces] operations in the South China Sea makes sense in the future,” he said.
“In the South China Sea, frankly, the Chinese fishing fleet, the Chinese coastguard and the (navy) overmatch their neighbors.”

An expansion of JMSDF patrols from the East China Sea into the South China Sea could be seen by Beijing as a provocative move on the behalf of Tokyo.

Japan – a staunch U.S. ally – has been at odds with China over the Senkaku/Diaoyu island chain at the Southern edge of the East China Sea and claimed a record number of interdictions against Chinese fighters in 2014.

China’s state-backed press has spent much ink comparing current Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe to the expansionist Imperial Japan of the early and mid-20th century and been highly critical of Japan’s new expansion of its defense posture from more of a policy of strictly self-defense.

Recently, Japan and the Philippines have discussed expanding their security relationship.

“For the Philippines, the issue is one of capacity. For the Japanese that is a perfect niche for them to help, not just in equipment, but in training and operations,” Thomas said.

For its part, the U.S. has walked a careful line of staying directly out of South China Sea territorial disputes but advocates for multi-lateral territorial settlements while Beijing prefers dealing with nations one-on-one.

Thomas said that China’s claims, including the so-called nine-dash line which intersects the internationally recognized territorial waters of several South China Sea countries, led to increased tension.

Vice Adm. Robert Thomas, 7th Fleet Commander

Vice Adm. Robert Thomas, 7th Fleet Commander

“The alleged nine-dash line, which doesn’t comport with international rules and norms, standards, laws, creates a situation down there, which is unnecessary friction,” he said.

This week, foreign ministers of countries in the Association of South East Asian Nations (ASEAN) have renewed called for a code of conduct in the South China Sea in response to Chinese land reclamation efforts that appear to be planned military bases in Spratly Islands.

“A number of countries raised the issue very strongly because they felt that the progress on the code of conduct was a little muted compared with the way in which land reclamation was being carried out,” said K. Shanmugam, Singapore’s minister for foreign affairs and law said on Wednesday, according to Jane’s Defence Weekly.

Whether or not Thomas comments to Reuters are an indication of a change in the U.S. position in the South China Sea, is unclear.

On Thursday, a Pentagon spokesman told USNI News Thomas’ words speak for themselves and did not say if the comments were part of larger policy shift in U.S. policy in the region.

Likewise, a Washington-based Navy spokesman would not comment on the interview and referred USNI News to 7th Fleet.

  • OleSalt_1

    It is favorable for the Japanese, Chinese, US and SE Asian Navies to patrol the South China Sea. We need to ensure sea lanes open & free from piracy and possible conflicts arising from territorial waters disputes. These should be settled amicably according to International Law. Common sense should rule, as the 21st Century growth in trade & commerce is supposed to be in the Asia-Pacific region (inc. South East & East Asia & India).

  • PolicyWonk

    The Chinese ham-handed claims on the S. China Sea, in absence of any validation from any international body – let alone the law of the sea – is creating a situation China claimed it didn’t want: to be surrounded by enemies.

    They are forcing old adversaries to band together and radically increase their defense budgets, because some nearly-senile folks in China think they have a score to settle with all their neighbors.

    The Chinese should have the sense to realize that they are basically pushing the Japanese into being vastly more active militarily, and could very well push the Japanese to start building nuclear weapons – the ultimate Chinese nightmare. And the Japanese have the technology to do exactly that in a very short period of time if they decided to do so.

    • SopheapAng

      And the “Trash” that pollute the native American land and the Hawaii islands is not?
      You should go back to kwok zucking instead of writing bullzhit.

    • SopheapAng

      And the “Trash” that pollute the native American land and the Hawaii islands is not?
      You should go back to kwok zucking instead of writing bullzhit.

    • old guy

      Please see my other post. The Chinese also have the nuclear technology and an excellent ICBM, MRBM and space program.

  • old guy

    The Japanese should be VERY careful. I saw a video of Chinese first graders playing a KILL game and the enemy was Japan. The “Rape of Nanking” is very much on the Chinese mind. I lost the site. If there is someone, skilled enough, that can pull it up I would appreciate it.