Home » Foreign Forces » What Whale Wars Can Teach the Navy


What Whale Wars Can Teach the Navy

sea-shepherd-shipThough the anti-whaling organization Sea Shepherd’s controversial tactics — popularized through the Animal Planet’s Whale Wars — polarize opinion between professional mariners and environmentalists, they are worthy of study as a maritime non-state actor.

Understanding their goals, strategies, operations, tactics, platforms and personnel can help Navy and Coast Guard elements deal with similar, but more violent organizations.

The size of western navies continues to decline – David Axe’s recent article “How to Sink a Navy” states that the Royal Navy’s reduction to a comparatively insignificant force has been a real game changer.

As Western powers slowly recede from the oceans, it is inevitable that before peer competitors might assume their hegemonic role, maritime security gaps will emerge making way for pirates, terrorists, and illicit traffickers to have comparatively greater reign.

In response to these maritime non-state actors, counter-entities like private security companies will continue to expand, albeit in fits and starts as has been the case off Somalia.

Although it has no conflict with U.S. interests and is a nuisance to Japanese whalers rather than a state threat, Sea Shepherd’s navy – or arguably “para-navy” – provides several important lessons to state navies in dealing with these threats.

Lesson #1: Maritime non-state actors evolve rapidly. This might sound obvious but some actors like pirates were rather stagnant in their approach and platforms. Terrorists like al-Qaeda continually adapt, but their maritime activity was limited.

Sea Shepherd, like the defunct Tamil Sea Tigers, has grown with every season employing more ships, with some now painted in dazzle camouflage patterns very similar to the U.S. Navy’s Littoral Combat Ship Freedom.

The group has acquired a variety of ships (such as the bio-diesel powered trimaran Brigitte Bardot), helicopters, and even commercially available unmanned aerial vehicles. This August, Sea Shepherd is expected to unveil its fifth ship, sailing a fleet that now aggregately out-displaces the navies of several small nations.

Lesson #2: Information operations can successfully support tactical advantages. Maritime non-state actors have skillfully utilized operational security and military deception.

In October 2012, for example, Women on Waves announced that they would enter Smir Harbor in Morocco. Patrol ships closed the harbor but unbeknownst to authorities, the organization had already sailed into the harbor.

Lesson #3: Media manipulation or exposure is a key component of successful maritime non-state actors.

Although it is more than three decades old, Sea Shepherd’s recent success is largely due to the boost in fund-raising from its television series on cable. They manage the cameras and tell their own story to the world in this reality series.

How would public perception change if the whalers filmed their own reality TV show on the battles in the Southern Ocean?

Lesson #4: Global operations are growing easier for maritime non-state actors. While the Tamil Tigers was largely a local actor, and many terror affiliates regional, Sea Shepherd has expanded its role globally from Antarctica to the Faroe Islands to Japan. This largely unprecedented reach suggests that it can rely on sympathetic supporters garnered from its media operations as well as benefitting from a multi-national crew.

Lesson #5: Lawfare is a key component of non-state operators. Environmental groups conducting “direct action” understand international law and find ways to exploit loopholes and skirt the edge of legality. Like pirates and other stateless groups have often done, Sea Shepherd routinely reflags and reclassifies its ships making it challenging for authorities to determine which laws and jurisdictions apply.

Perhaps most importantly, groups like Sea Shepherds challenge state navies and coast guards for the monopoly of violence on the high seas. If navies continue their decline and the rule of law further erodes in international waters, the world can expect more non-state groups to fill the maritime security vacuum.

  • Pat Patterson

    Sea Shepherds is just a quasi-terrorist organization. They and other organizations have no function as security organizations.

    • Bradley Sugden

      Pat Patterson the Sea Shepherd Conservation Society has done more to save marine life than any other organization. Even though the sea shepherds may not be a qualified security organization, the sea shepherds’ success in the past and present says otherwise. Mankind is destroying the ocean and unbalancing the fragile ecosystem left,right,and center. The oceans are the foundation for all life on this planet. What both of you need to realize is that if our oceans die,we die. It’s just that simple. We can’t live on this planet with a dead ocean. No oceans. No civilization. No humanity. “He who does not value life does not deserve it.” -Leonardo da Vinci.

      • Sandy

        enviro-whacko boy – whaling was going on for hundreds of years without anything affecting the planet – it fed people…who are you for – whales or people? Stop with your pajama-boy pillow-biting “woe is the planet” rhetoric. There are only two things that control the planet – the sun and volcanoes – and both of them are the product of GOD ALMIGHTY. Man makes plans, and GOD laughs.

        • Jordan B

          so which God is that? Thor, Zeus, Ra, or one of the 3600 dieties which dont exist?

          Im pretty sure that if a God existed, it wouldnt be his plan to harvest cavier for the rich…

          • Sandy

            The LIVING GOD….this is not heaven…this is a testing ground. You might want to remember that.

          • Jordan B

            Sorry, I’m still unsure of which god you are referring to. The one that gives kids cancer and makes rappers famous? Belief if so often the death of reason .

      • old guy

        VERY NICE PLATITUDES. I wish that their generalities had led to some realistic actions. FIRST, In the ’70s, When I was NAVSEA003, at the behest of the head of Greenpeace, my people helped design the “RAINBOW WARRIOR” on their own time. He has since RESIGNED, in disgust, because the weep and moan Green Religion people have usurped his once well directed cause. I’m afraid that you sound like one of them.

      • Jordan B

        Your absolutely correct. Unfortunately the antiquated posters on this board still think that the earth and animals on it are less important then they are. Once that ignorant generation is gone , we may have more hope. And less diabetes and churches.

  • allbuss84

    One day they will push too far and the Japanese navy will sink their ships. Hopefully that day is soon and hopefully it is on camera. I’ll tune in for that episode.

    • Bradley Sugden

      allbuss84 the Sea Shepherd Conservation Society has done more to save marine life than any other organization. Even though the sea shepherds may not be a qualified security organization, the sea shepherds’ success in the past and present says otherwise. Mankind is destroying the ocean and unbalancing the fragile ecosystem left,right,and center. The oceans are the foundation for all life on this planet. What both of you need to realize is that if our oceans die,we die. It’s just that simple. We can’t live on this planet with a dead ocean. No oceans. No civilization. No humanity. “He who does not value life does not deserve it.” -Leonardo da Vinci.

      • Sandy

        fishing some whales isn’t killing the ocean, idiot. If fact, it will provide food for people. People can’t live on raman noodles alone.

  • Bradley Sugden

    Pat Patterson and allbuss84 the Sea Shepherd Conservation Society has done more to save marine life than any other organization. Even though the sea shepherds may not be a qualified security organization, the sea shepherds’ success in the past and present says otherwise. Mankind is destroying the ocean and unbalancing the fragile ecosystem left,right,and center. The oceans are the foundation for all life on this planet. What both of you need to realize is that if our oceans die,we die. It’s just that simple. We can’t live on this planet with a dead ocean. No oceans. No civilization. No humanity. “He who does not value life does not deserve it.” -Leonardo da Vinci.

  • http://nickysworld.wordpress.com/ Nicky

    One day when Japan pushes too far, Japan may send a Frigate Task force to protect their commerce. It would not surprise me if Japan sends a Frigate or a Destroyer to chase down She Sheppard. If the US Coast Guard had to do it, they would be facing a National Security cutter with a 57mm Bofars Cannon pointed right at them with 25mm Cannons pointed on them. All while a Boarding team fast ropes on board and seizes the ship, crew and bring them back to US to face charges.

  • Sandy

    the Sea Shepherds are a highly funded group of absolutely disorganized marijuana infused clowns…watching their operations is like watching the Keystone Cops. They had to get rid of the First Officer (name escapes me) for negligence (he also said he was “anti-military”) – he butted heads with a former USN female SWO who now turned rogue. I root for the whaling ships; had the pleasure of foiling Watson’s plans for disrupting the D-5 missile tests off Florida in 1989 twice – 2 USN salvage ships put a nice size hole in the RAINBOW WARRIOR by “shouldering it” out of the area while we policed up the hippies in the small boats – absolutely hilarious story. Chris Rawley…what makes you qualified to speak about “Unconventional Warfare” – do you even know what the term means? It is not “warfare which is not-conventional” which you seem to proclaim in your book – it is a specific mission set in Special Forces for force multiplication which was the first mission set in AFG. You speak of Special Warfare and Irregular Warfare, not “unconventional warfare”…..I did 20 in the Teams and contracting in the IC, so please spare me any diatribe. The Sea Shepherds are worthy of watching them for comedic relief, and that’s it. Perhaps you should stick to ship driving.